As the world of football eagerly awaits the resolution of Everton and Nottingham Forest’s cases regarding the Premier League’s Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR’s), Richard Masters, the CEO of the EPL, has responded strongly to the government’s Culture, Media & Sport Committee.
Previously, there were suggestions from the committee that Masters had implied that both Everton and Forest were not considered ‘major’ clubs. In his response, the chief executive aimed to clarify his previous statements.
“In regards to your question about whether a distinction is made between ‘big’ and ‘small’ clubs within the Premier League, it is important to note that I was asked this question by a Committee Member who used the term ‘big clubs’ when discussing cynicism towards certain clubs’ ability to use legal means to prolong or avoid cases,” he replied in a letter addressed to Dame Caroline Dinenage, the Chair of the committee.
“As I stated in my testimony, Everton and Nottingham Forest are valued and respected members of the Premier League. Both clubs have rich histories, passionate fanbases, and contribute significantly not only to the Premier League’s competitive landscape but also to their respective cities and local communities.
“By reflecting the Committee Member’s phrasing of the question, I did not intend to suggest otherwise. It would be incorrect to infer from this that there is any unfair treatment based on club size, as implied in the committee’s media statement.
“In fact, my point was quite the opposite, emphasizing that the Premier League Board applies the rules consistently, regardless of the club in question.”
The primary concern for many revolves around the speed at which Everton and Nottingham Forest’s cases are being handled, especially considering that Manchester City, the reigning Premier League champions, have over 100 ongoing allegations against them but have yet to face questioning regarding their alleged misconduct.
“You raise concerns regarding fairness and transparency in the recent Everton case and request access to certain confidential documents,” Masters continued.
“We acknowledge the role of the Select Committee in holding the government accountable and seeking insights from relevant industries regarding public policy matters. We appreciate the opportunity to provide input and answer questions.
“However, as a private business, it is not our practice to disclose or publish minutes from Premier League Board Meetings. Additionally, we are unable to publish submissions made by the Premier League Board or Executive as part of confidential legal proceedings.
“Nevertheless, I hope to address the committee’s queries as this is an important matter, and I am grateful for the chance to provide further clarification following my oral testimony to the committee.
“Throughout this process, the Premier League has consistently treated the club fairly and respectfully. As the organizer and administrator of the competition, it is also our responsibility to ensure fairness for clubs that have adhered to the rules.
“This entails enforcing our rulebook consistently and impartially.”
Masters clearly took offense at any insinuation that the Commission overseeing potential points deductions or other decisions was not fully independent.
“The committee’s media statement suggests that this submission from the Commission somehow compromises its independence,” he added.
“As I explained to the committee, the Judicial Panel and the selected Commission responsible for this case are entirely independent of the league.
“The panel members are appointed by an independent chair through a process in which the league has no involvement, and the members of each commission are appointed independently by that chair, again without any league interference.
“Each member of the independent commission that heard this case was a highly experienced lawyer or financial expert, including one former member of the judiciary.”
For the supporters of both Premier League clubs, the outcome of these proceedings could determine whether they remain in the top-flight of English football or face relegation.
According to the Source caughtoffside.com